1144 BLUE HILL CREEK DRIVE, Marco Island, FL 34145 (MLS# 2260231)

Island Location: Key Marco

Community: Marco Island

Subarea Type: Water Direct

Property SubType: Single Family Residence

Listing Contract Date: 2026-01-29

List Price: $6,850,000

Current Price: $6,850,000

Tax Unit: 0

Tax Block: 5

Tax Lot: 7

Parcel Number: 50940004268

Tax Annual Amount: 21500

Tax Year: 2025

Special Assessment: No

Furnished: Unfurnished

Flood Plain: No

A/C SqFt: 6836

Bathrooms Half: 2

Lot Size Dimensions: 145x233x143x240

Stories: 3

Total Baths: 8

# Office Den: 2

Rear Exposure: South

Garage Spaces: 3

Boat Dock: Yes

Boat Lift: Permittable

Pool Private Y/N: Yes

Spa Y/N: Yes

HOA Y/N: Yes

HOA Fee: 584

CDD/CID: Yes

Annual CDD/CID Payment: 1700

Total Area-SqFt: 10482

Year Built: 2004

Bedrooms Total: 5

Bathrooms Full: 6

Public Remarks: Escape to your island sanctuary where one can truly get away from it all. Set on nearly one-acre with southern exposure, this incredibly private residence in Key Marco has an amazing backdrop of Barfield Bay, colorful sunrises and sunsets, the Marco Island skyline in the distance all while being surrounded by the lush preserve. This elegant, light and bright, 6,800+ air-conditioned square-foot residence over three floors with private elevator offers five en-suite bedrooms plus den(s), six-full and two-half baths, formal/informal living and dining spaces and numerous outdoor terraces where one can take in the vistas and the sights and sounds of the area's nature and wildlife. The home was masterfully built with incredible quality of construction, craftsmanship and with the really high elevation adds to the overall feeling of safety and security. Extensive updates made throughout in the recent years (list available) but the most notable would be the addition of the state-of-the-art heated saltwater swimming pool and oversized spa with expansive decking, open-air and covered space, retaining walls and an outdoor kitchen creating a spa-like, serene environment which is ideal for basking in the sun, feeling the beautiful breeze, swimming laps, reading a book or entertaining. This home is the epitome of the southwest Florida lifestyle; elegant but casual with plenty of space to unwind, sit back, relax and enjoy the view from every room and every floor. Whether watching a summer storm roll in or gazing at the stars at night- there is nothing not to fall in love with! Spacious, air-conditioned three-car garage that was renovated in 2024 with fresh paint, epoxy floors with anti-skid finish, commercial shelving/mounting hardware and a Tesla EV charger. Key Marco is a beautiful historical, gated hidden-gem community that is very private and offers direct access boat slips (assigned), tennis/pickleball, fitness and community center. The quiet and tranquility are what beckons people here and yet, you are within six miles to the beach, area restaurants, fitness centers, grocery and essential stores, additional shopping and more. This home has been lovingly maintained by the owners and is a must-see to truly appreciate everything it has to offer.

Road Frontage Length: 145

Contemporary: 1

Mediterranean: 1

Tennis Available Daily: 1

Tennis Included: 1

Cooktop: 1

Dryer: 1

Microwave: 1

Oven: 1

Refrigerator With Ice Maker: 1

Washer: 1

Buyer: 1

See Remarks: 1

Bike Path: 1

Clubhouse: 1

Fishing Pier: 1

Fitness Center: 1

Jogging Path: 1

Pickleball: 1

Pier: 1

Tennis Court(s): 1

Concrete Block Structure: 1

Stucco: 1

2 or More Systems: 1

Ceiling Fan(s): 1

Central Air: 1

At Close: 1

Buyer Obtain Mortgage: 1

Cash: 1

2 or More Systems: 1

Central Heating: 1

Assigned: 1

See Remarks: 1

Balcony: 1

Built-in Barbecue: 1

Outdoor Kitchen: 1

Breakfast Bar: 1

Breakfast Room: 1

Eat-in Kitchen: 1

Separate Dining Room: 1

Carpet: 1

Natural Stone: 1

Tile: 1

City Lot: 1

County Lot: 1

Mid Street Location: 1

Lease - Times Per Year: 1

Min # Days For Lease: 90

Max # Days For Lease: 365

Built-in Features: 1

Custom Closets: 1

Elevator: 1

Entrance Foyer: 1

French Doors: 1

Gas Fireplace: 1

Tray Ceiling(s): 1

Volume Ceiling(s): 1

Walk-In Closet(s): 1

Wet Bar: 1

Laundry Tub: 1

Attached: 1

Garage: 1

Resale: 1

Tile: 1

Gated Community: 1

Gated with Guard: 1

Sewer Central: 1

See Remarks: 1

City: 1

Propane Tank: 1

Public: 1

Three Or More: 1

Lanai: Open

Patio: 1

Porch: Screened

Listing Agent has no Relationship with Seller: 1

Bidet: 1

Double Vanity: 1

Enclosed Toilet: 1

Primary Upstairs: 1

Separate Tub & Shower: 1

Split Bedrooms: 1

City: 1

County: 1

Architectural Plans: 1

Bay: 1

Long Water: 1

Trees/Woods: 1

Wide Water: 1

Access Gulf: 1

See Remarks: 1

Impact Doors: 1

Impact Windows: 1

Sliding: 1

Electric Heat: 1

In-Ground: 1

Pool Bath: 1

Salt Water: 1

Street Number: 1144

Street Name: BLUE HILL CREEK

Street Suffix: DRIVE

County: Collier

State: FL

Postal Code: 34145

Subdivision Name: Horr'S Island Aka Key Marco

Status: Active